
This is a charming and important book about Pacific exploration. I read it once -- so long ago I’ve forgotten precisely why it impressed me. However, at my advanced age I don’t need to remember details. All I need to remember is that it’s an important title and, roughly, how much it might be worth in today’s market. For the rest I can go to The Hill Collection of Pacific Voyages.
Every trade has its tools. As surely as the mechanic relies on his socket wrenches, or the dentist his drill, we booksellers depend on our reference books. And the Hill Collection is one of the best of them.
Kenneth Hill made his money in Big Oil, advising people like J. Paul Getty and Armand Hammer. He began collecting Pacific Voyages in the 1960s, and his keen intellect, advanced organizational skills, and relatively deep pockets enabled him to assemble a world-class collection in short order. He donated his collection to the recently formed University of California at San Diego in the mid-1970s. The collection was cataloged, annotated, and published in three volumes between 1974 and 1983.
No one had ever compiled such a thorough list of printed voyages, and no one had previously taken the pains to write such detailed and accurate notes, describing the particularities of each title and often placing the individual work in the greater context of world history and politics. People in our trade realized immediately what an important reference book it was. I bought my set at auction for $750 in the late 1980s. $750 was a lot of money back then, but the Hill Collection has repaid that investment hundreds of times over.
Still, it was a rather difficult book to use. There were three different volumes of listings, the listed titles were not numbered in any sequential way, and there were some titles missing. Indeed, much to the annoyance of the compilers, we booksellers would not hesitate to brag that a title we were offering was “not in Hill.” They claimed they were simply cataloging a collection, not writing a comprehensive bibliography. And anyway, they were adding to the collection continuously.
All this got remedied by a second, revised, edition published in 2004. Errors have been corrected, new titles have been added, and the disparate volumes have been combined into a single alphabetical listing, with each title having its own reference number. It’s a vastly improved work, a model of what a bibliographical reference book should be. I’m even mentioned in the “Acknowledgements” section though, as with Jacobs’s book, I’ve forgotten why.
Here’s Hill’s note about the book:

And here’s my description:
Jacobs, Thomas Jefferson. SCENES, INCIDENTS AND ADVENTURES IN THE PACIFIC OCEAN... DURING THE CRUISE OF THE CLIPPER MARGARET OAKLEY, UNDER CAPT. BENJAMIN MORRELL. NY. 1844. b/w plates and ills. xi-372 pp. “Clearing up the mystery which has heretofore surrounded this famous expedition, and containing a full account of the exploration of the Bidera, Papua, Banda, Mindoro, Sooloo, and China Seas, the manners and customs of the inhabitants...” Jacobs left the ship in Singapore and returned home to write this book which is, according to Hill, “apart from the vivid accounts of the islands and ports visited, an early and clear declaration of what was soon to become the U.S. policy of Manifest Destiny” - Hill 876. And Morrell, of course, was a character in his own right. (In his note to Morrell’s Narrative of Four Voyages Hill notes that he had been called “the biggest liar in the Pacific. – See Hill 1186.) Ferguson 3844. Howes J-38. Smith J.6. Scattered foxing, light water stain, but still a Good-VG copy. The large folding view of Canton is loose but present, with an old closed tear along one fold and no loss.
Next week I’ll talk about how I priced this book, and the tools I use to price books and manuscripts.










